ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer: A Strategic Tool for Nonprofit Leaders

Your brand is more than your logo. It’s a container for your reputation, a promise you make to your supporters, and the banner under which your community gathers. In the social impact sector, your reputation is built on two pillars: the power of your story and the proof of your impact. While you work tirelessly to craft the former, the latter is often quantified in a place many leaders overlook—your annual IRS Form 990.

This public document is not just a compliance headache; it’s a detailed financial narrative of your organization’s priorities, operations, and health. And thanks to tools like the ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer, your 990—and those of your peers, partners, and competitors—is more accessible than ever.

For the savvy nonprofit leader, this isn’t a threat. It’s a powerful opportunity to gather intelligence, benchmark performance, and ensure the story your financials tell aligns with the mission-driven brand you’re building.

What is the ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer?

At its core, the ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer is a free, user-friendly database that collects and digitizes the information tax-exempt organizations report to the IRS. It provides a simple way to search for any nonprofit and view key financial data, compensation for top leaders, and full copies of their Form 990 filings for several years.

But to see it as just a database is to miss the point entirely. It’s a strategic landscape waiting to be mapped. It allows you to look beyond the polished annual reports and compelling websites to understand the operational and financial realities of the social impact sector. Using it effectively can help you move your organization from unremarkable to unforgettable.

Understanding Your Ecosystem: Using the Explorer for External Intelligence

To build a distinct and powerful brand, you must first understand the environment in which you operate. The Nonprofit Explorer is an invaluable tool for gaining this crucial context.

Benchmark Your Financial Story

How does your organization’s financial structure compare to others in your field? By reviewing the 990s of organizations with a similar mission and budget, you can start to answer critical questions:

• Program Spending: What percentage of their budget goes directly to programs? How does your program ratio compare, and can you articulate why?
• Fundraising Efficiency: How much are they spending to raise a dollar? This can reveal different fundraising philosophies and help you evaluate your own approach.
• Administrative Costs: So-called "overhead" is often misunderstood, but benchmarking can help you frame your own administrative and operational investments as essential infrastructure for impact, not a necessary evil.

This data provides a vital reality check. It helps you set realistic goals and communicate your financial story to your board and funders with confidence and context.

Identify and Vet Potential Partners

Collaboration is key to solving complex social problems. Before entering a partnership, you can use the Explorer to perform due diligence. Reviewing a potential partner's 990s can give you a snapshot of their financial stability, leadership, and programmatic priorities. A healthy, stable partner is essential for a successful long-term collaboration. This is a crucial step in protecting your own brand and ensuring your joint efforts can be sustained.

Discover New Funding Prospects

One of the most powerful features of the Explorer is the ability to see who funds whom. Private foundations also file 990s (the 990-PF), which list all the grants they have awarded.

By looking at foundations that support organizations similar to yours, you can build a highly qualified list of prospective funders who have already demonstrated an interest in your issue area. This transforms your grant-seeking from a shot in the dark into a strategic, data-informed process, helping you find funders who are already aligned with your vision.

Telling Your Own Story: Using the Explorer for Internal Strategy

Just as the Explorer provides a window into other organizations, it also acts as a mirror for your own. Donors, journalists, and major funders are already using this tool to look at you. Your job is to understand what they see and use that knowledge to build a more integrated, resilient, and magnetic brand.

Align Your Financials with Your Narrative

Your website tells a story of change. Your emails share powerful beneficiary testimonials. Your social media shows your G. Does your Form 990 support that narrative?

If your brand story is about innovation and growth, but your 990 shows stagnant revenue and minimal investment in your team, there’s a disconnect. This is where many nonprofits falter. They silo their fundraising, marketing, and program functions, resulting in a fragmented brand. Your 990 should be seen as a core marketing document. Every line item, from program expenses to marketing investment, should reinforce the central story of your mission and impact.

Make the Case for Foundational Investment

Many nonprofits operate with a "scrappiness fallacy," believing that underinvesting in marketing, technology, and people is a badge of honor. The 990s of highly successful organizations often tell a different story. They show strategic investment in the infrastructure needed for long-term growth.

Your 990 can be the catalyst for a critical internal conversation. Are you investing in the digital platforms required for modern, relationship-based communications?

• A Centralized CRM: Is there a line item reflecting an investment in a robust customer relationship management (CRM) system? Without it, your supporter data remains fragmented, making it impossible to deliver the personalized, human-centered messaging that builds lasting loyalty.
• A Powerful Digital Hub: Your website is your brand's digital front door. It must be more than an online brochure; it needs to be an integrated hub for storytelling, community-building, and activation. Strategic investment in your digital presence shows up on a 990, and it’s non-negotiable in today’s attention economy.
• A Narrative-Driven Email Platform: Are you equipped with the tools to move beyond generic email blasts? The right platform allows for sophisticated automation and segmentation, freeing up your team to focus on crafting the compelling, scroll-stopping stories that inspire action.

Using data from peer organizations via the Explorer, you can show your board what effective investment looks like and make the case for building a strong foundation that transforms your activation from invisible to magnetic.

Build Trust Through Transparency

Ultimately, your Form 990 is a public declaration of your stewardship. By proactively understanding your own financial data, you can prepare for tough questions and frame your numbers in the context of your mission.

This transparency is the antidote to the transactional, fear-based tactics that erode trust. A leader who can confidently walk a donor through their 990, explaining how every dollar fuels their theory of change, is building a brand based on credibility and authenticity. This is how you build a resilient reputation and nurture a community that will stand with you for the long haul.

From Data to a Movement

The ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer doesn't tell you what to do. It gives you the data and context to make smarter strategic decisions. It allows you to see your organization not as an island, but as a part of a dynamic ecosystem.

Turning that data into a powerful brand narrative, however, requires a holistic and integrated approach. It requires breaking down the silos between fundraising and marketing, investing in strong digital foundations, and committing to a long-term vision of brand building. When you weave together a compelling impact story with a financial narrative of strategic, mission-aligned investment, you create a brand that is truly unforgettable.

---

Ready to transform your organization’s brand from fragmented to integrated? The first step is a clear strategy. Book a free strategy call with Cosmic to discuss how we can help you build the foundation for sustainable growth.

Learn more about our holistic approach with the Social Impact Growth Model, where we provide an entire team of strategists, designers, and developers dedicated to helping you nail your impact story and mobilize your community.